Raymond F. Sis1, DVM, PhD; Andre M. Landry2, PhD; Gerald
R. Bratton1, DVM, PhD
Recent documentation of sea turtle strandings on Texas beaches has raised
questions about the cause for these elevated mortalities. These strandings have also enhanced
public concern for the integrity of the coastal environment in the Gulf of Mexico. Since Texas
is the site of three major industries - chemical, shrimp, and oil- whose operations are
perceived in conflict with the well-being of sea turtle stocks, it is important to determine
what role, if any, these industries may have played in the recent increase in sea turtle
deaths.
Chemical pollutants introduced either anthropogenically or naturally could
affect sea turtles. Petroleum hydrocarbons (oil and its derivatives) are continuously released
in large volume by natural seepage from the sea floor, while metals are naturally leached from
rocks and minerals on the sea floor. However, it is the site specific release of large amounts
of oil, such as the release of oil in Kuwait, the Exxon Valdez spill, or the Megaborg spill,
that create major problems and generate the most press coverage. Industrial waste of many kinds
frequently contains high concentrations of toxic metals (Hg, As, Pb, Cd), so that dumping or
release into the ocean causes focal areas of high concentration. Some heavy metals such as Cu,
Se, Fe, and Zn are essential for proper metabolism, but even these elements commonly used in
industrial technology can be released in such high concentrations that they become highly
toxic.
Organochlorines, for example DDT and its more toxic decomposition compounds,
DDD and DDE, are anthropogenic pesticides which have been dumped into the oceans and will
continue to remain in the marine environment. These pesticides, as well as numerous others
developed in the past and currently being developed by the chemical industry, are major dangers
to the marine environment.
The effect of pollutants on sea turtles is difficult to evaluate because the
animals are not confined to an easily studied habitat. The size and life span of turtles as well
as regulatory restrictions on endangered and threatened species prevents contained laboratory
studies of these animals. This paper focuses on measurement of selected heavy metal,
organochlorine pesticide, and poly-aromatic hydrocarbon concentrations found in sea turtles
stranded on the Texas coast during a specific point in time (July 10 to July 13, 1990).
Four days after the beginning of the Texas Gulf shrimping season (July 6,
1990) 30 endangered sea turtles were found dead within the next four days (July 10 to July 13)
along the upper Texas Gulf Coast. Thirteen loggerheads (Caretta caretta) and 17 Kemp's
ridleys (Lepidochelys kempi) comprised this standing event. Necropsies were performed on
all 30 turtles. Although some were severely autolyzed, liver, kidney, and visceral fat were
collected from 20 of the less autolyzed specimens and frozen for toxicological analysis. Prior
to the July 10 to July 13 strandings, similar tissues had been collected from 15 stranded
turtles (5 loggerheads and 10 Kemp's ridleys). Additional samples were collected from 20
stranded turtles (3 loggerheads and 17 Kemp's ridleys) between July 25 and September 25, a
period after the focal time in question.
The objective of this study was to determine if pollutants were elevated in
tissue from turtles found dead on the Texas coast between July 10 and July 13. Liver, kidney and
visceral fat were analyzed from 10 randomly selected loggerhead turtles (two from the group
collected prior to July 10, six from the time period in question, and two from the group
collected after July 13). The prior and post turtles were used as controls for the animals found
dead between July 10 and July 13. Zinc, Cu, Fe, Cd, Pb, As, and Se were measured by atomic
absorption spectroscopy in liver and kidney, while 15 selected organochlorine pesticides and 5
poly aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) were measured in visceral fat by organic extraction and gas
chromatographic - mass spectroscopic analysis.
Zinc, Fe, Se, Pb, and Cu levels were within ranges previously reported for
freshwater turtles, sea turtles, marine mammals, and farm animals. Mercury and As concentrations
were within the range reported for many land animals and for bowhead whales, as recently
determined in our laboratory (data reported elsewhere). Cadmium levels were elevated when
compared to levels reported in other turtle studies, but were within the range reported for
whales and dolphins and generally well below levels reported in terrestrial animals with known
Cd toxicity. In no case was the metal level in the turtles in question significantly different
from turtles that died before or after the July 10 to July 13 date. It is highly unlikely that
any of these turtles died as a result of metal toxicity.
No consistent pattern of organochlorine pesticides was found in the turtles
tested and the levels found were well below levels considered dangerous in eggs or fish used for
human consumption. No PAHs were detected in any tissue. It is clear that these pollutants did
not pose a health risk to any of the turtles analyzed.
In conclusion, the pollutants measured were not excessively elevated in any
of the tissues for the turtles of this study and there were no differences between groups. These
findings, along with the absence of pathological confirmation of toxicity or disease, would seem
to rule out pollutant-induced death in these turtles. One must then pay attention to the
correlation of the marked elevation of strandings within a few days of the onset of shrimping
season.